LensMount

Articles · · 6 min read

Why you can't put mirrorless lenses on a DSLR

Mirrorless lenses sit 16–20 mm from the sensor; DSLR mounts hold lenses 38.67–46.5 mm away. Why that gap can't be bridged, and the rare exceptions.

A mirrorless lens cannot be adapted to a DSLR because it would sit too far from the sensor. Mirrorless lenses are designed to sit between 16.0 and 20.0 mm from the sensor; DSLR mounts hold the lens between 38.67 mm (Four Thirds) and 46.5 mm (Nikon F) away to make room for the mirror. An adapter can only add distance, never remove it, so the lens would behave like it was on an extension tube: it could focus close up but never at infinity. Fixing that needs corrective glass in the adapter, and even then most mirrorless lenses have no aperture ring or mechanical controls a DSLR could operate.

The opposite direction, DSLR lens onto mirrorless body, works for exactly the same reason. The rest of this post explains why the geometry only runs one way.

Flange distance, in reverse

Every mount has a flange focal distance: the gap between the mount face and the sensor. A lens is built for its own mount’s figure. Adapting is only possible when the body’s flange distance is shorter than the lens’s, because the adapter fills the difference. See flange focal distance explained for the full principle.

Here is what happens if you try to put mirrorless lenses on the matching maker’s DSLR:

Mirrorless lensFlangeDSLR bodyFlangeLens would sit this much too far away
Canon RF20.0 mmCanon EF44.0 mm24.0 mm
Nikon Z16.0 mmNikon F46.5 mm30.5 mm
Sony E18.0 mmSony A44.5 mm26.5 mm
Micro Four Thirds19.25 mmFour Thirds38.67 mm19.42 mm

Those figures are before adding any adapter at all. There is no thickness of adapter, including zero, that puts the lens in the right place.

What “too far away” does to the picture

Moving a lens further from the sensor is exactly what a macro extension tube does. The lens focuses closer than it was designed to, and loses the ability to focus on anything distant. With 24–30 mm of extra spacing, a normal lens would only focus a short distance in front of it. Landscapes, street scenes and anything beyond arm’s length would be permanently blurred.

The mirror box

The long flange distance of a DSLR is not arbitrary. The mirror sits between the lens and the sensor and swings up for each exposure, and it needs clear space to do so. That space is why every SLR mount in this site’s data has a flange distance of 38.67 mm or more, against 16.0–20.0 mm for the mirrorless mounts.

Canon’s own history shows the problem. EF-S lenses share the EF flange distance, but their rear element protrudes far enough to foul the mirror of a full-frame Canon SLR, so they cannot be used on one. Mirrorless lenses were designed with no mirror to avoid, so there is no reason their rear elements would respect that space either.

Could an adapter with glass fix it?

In principle, partly. An adapter containing a corrective lens group can shift the point of focus so that a lens mounted too far back reaches infinity again. That glass acts as a teleconverter: it magnifies the image, costs light, and adds its own aberrations.

There is a real precedent. When Canon moved from FD to EF in 1987, FD lenses were stranded, because FD’s 42.0 mm flange distance is shorter than EF’s 44.0 mm, by only 2 mm. Canon made an FD-to-EOS adapter with high-quality corrective optics that worked as a 1.26× teleconverter, and it could not be used on lenses shorter than 200 mm. Even Canon, solving a 2 mm problem for its own lenses, got a compromise. A 24–30 mm problem is far worse. This site’s advice on third-party FD-to-EF adapters with glass still stands: they degrade the image and exist only to solve a problem mirrorless does not have. See Canon FD lenses on Sony E for the painless alternative.

The electronic problem

Suppose the optics were solved. The next obstacle is control.

Most mirrorless lenses have no mechanical aperture ring or aperture lever. The camera sets the aperture, drives the focus motor and reads the lens data through the mount’s electronic contacts, using that maker’s protocol. This site records the practical result in its mount data as “adapts out: impractical” for Nikon Z, Canon RF, L-Mount, Micro Four Thirds, Canon EF-M and Fujifilm G: electronically controlled, with no aperture ring to fall back on.

A DSLR body does not speak a mirrorless mount’s protocol. An adapter would have to translate every command, and with no aperture ring there is no manual fallback. A lens that cannot be told what to do would be stuck at whatever aperture it rests at, with no autofocus.

Compare old SLR lenses going the other way. A Canon FD or M42 lens has its own aperture ring, so a plain ring is enough. The site’s data marks these “mechanical only”: nothing needs to talk to anything.

Mirrorless to mirrorless: mostly impractical

Swapping lenses between mirrorless systems runs into the same maths with smaller numbers. Current mirrorless flange distances are packed into a 4 mm range, from 16.0 mm (Nikon Z) to 20.0 mm (Canon RF and L-Mount). An adapter needs a lens mount that is longer than the body’s, by enough to build a working adapter, with a mount opening wide enough to fit the lens’s bayonet inside it.

A few pairs clear both hurdles.

Sony E onto Nikon Z

Sony E’s 18.0 mm is 2.0 mm longer than Nikon Z’s 16.0 mm, and Nikon Z has a 55 mm throat, the widest of the current full-frame mounts. That is enough for an electronic adapter. Megadap’s ETZ21 Pro series and Techart’s TZE adapters translate Sony’s protocol into Nikon’s, with autofocus, auto aperture and eye detection listed as supported. Results are lens-dependent and change with firmware. See Sony E lenses on Nikon Z.

Search Amazon UK

Fujifilm X onto Nikon Z

Fujifilm X’s 17.7 mm leaves 1.7 mm over Nikon Z. Electronic adapters have appeared for it, including the Shoten XTZ and Boryoza FX-Z, both sold as passing autofocus and aperture control through. This site has not yet rated this pair, and Shoten itself cautions that autofocus accuracy and speed vary with the camera and lens.

The pairs that don’t work

Where to go next